Monday, December 4, 2017

The Organic Development of The Liturgy


·      Author: Dom Alcuin Reid
·      Pages: 374 pages
·      Publisher:  Ignasius Press, San Francisco (2005)
·      Language: English

About the Author

Dom Alcuin Reid is a monk of the Monastère Saint-Benoît in the Diocese of Fréjus-Toulon, France. After studies in Theology and in Education in Melbourne, Australia, he was awarded a PhD from King’s College, University of London, for a thesis on twentieth century liturgical reform (2002), which was subsequently published as The Organic Development of the Liturgy with a preface by Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (this book).


Structure

Introduction
Chapter One             Liturgical Reform in History
Chapter Two             The Liturgical Movement and Liturgical Reform up to 1948
Chapter Three           The Liturgical Movement and Liturgical Reform from 1948 to the Second Vatican Council
General Conclusion
Appendix
Bibliography
Endnotes

Scope


Dom Alcuin Reid’s book wants to run through the history of the Roman Rite (Mass and Breviary), from its beginnings up to the eve of the Second Vatican Council. Reid seeks to establish the principles of liturgical development, and thus to draw from history — from its ups and downs — the standards on which every reform must be based. He believes that we must grasp the principles of liturgical reform operative in the history of the Roman rite and the relationship of the Liturgical Movement to the reformer of the liturgy (eg. Guéranger, Saint Pius X, Beauduin, Guardini, Parsch, Casel, and others). Only then can discussion of the legitimacy of any “reform of the reform”, or of its possible shape, be sufficiently informed.


THESIS

The book is divided into three parts.

The first, very brief (necessarily brief) part investigates the history of the reform of the Roman Rite from its beginnings up to the end of the nineteenth century. Significant reforms and the principles operative therein are considered. Concerning liturgical reform up to 1900, the author concludes: “At the close of the nineteenth century, a healthy respect for the Roman rite as a developed organic reality exists” (60). Moreover, in support of this, he quotes Fortescue: “The Roman Rite arrived at this point in history much developed indeed, but still that living organism that was the Roman Liturgy of the first Christian millennium. The developments had been prompted in part by necessity, and in part by the vicissitudes of history. Care had been taken to respect objective liturgical Tradition and to develop it organically. Reforms that were not organic were eventually proscribed” (60-61).

Part two is devoted to the Liturgical Movement up to 1948. The second chapter details the origins of the Liturgical Movement and demonstrates its nature as primarily a movement seeking to return liturgical piety to its rightfully central place in the life of the Church. The Movement’s consequent consideration of the desirability of liturgical reform and the stance taken by the Holy See with regard to the Liturgical Movement and to liturgical reform are examined. Again, the author’s conclusion concerning this phase was a favourable one: “The Liturgical Movement, then, approached its fortieth birthday . . . in good health and with a largely traditional and moderate mentality with regard to reform. .. Even though some reprobate practices arose, the Movement’s essence was to comprehend objective liturgical Tradition in order to give shape and meaning to Christian life, and indeed to society” (131).

The longest part — the third — deals with liturgical reform under Pius XII, up to the eve of the Second Vatican Council. The reforms enacted by the Holy See throughout this period are studied as are the parallel activities and writings of the Liturgical Movement in relation to liturgical reform. The author summing up of this phase, though it contains some praise, ends with a warning: “The Liturgical Movement achieved much between 1948 and the opening of the Second Vatican Council. Its goal of placing liturgical piety at the center of the life of the Church, underlined by Pius XII in Mediator Dei, was adopted and widely promoted by numerous individuals and groups . . . .A momentum, an expectation of, if not a thirst for, further reforms, builds up, pre-eminently among European liturgists and scholars, which could only intensify with the establishment of the preparatory liturgical commission for the forthcoming Council. There is a sense among some writers that almost everything is negotiable, resulting in at least an implicit devaluation of the objective nature of liturgical Tradition: something foreign to the Liturgical Movement in its origins” (282-283).

The general conclusion of the author concerning the effect of the Council is: “To some extent, then, we may say that reform moved too quickly prior to the Council. More time needed to be spent preparing the foundations before renovating the edifice . . .. Whilst clearly a metaphor, ‘organic development’ is, nevertheless, the metaphor employed by key persons throughout the Liturgical Movement and indeed by the Second Vatican Council itself when speaking of liturgical reform . . . . We conclude, then, that this, the principle, or law, of the organic development of objective liturgical Tradition, is indeed the sine qua non of Catholic liturgical reform . . . . However some of the Movement’s activists pressuring for reform before the Second Vatican Council moved beyond its bounds . . . . The task of a thorough assessment of whether this law was respected in the reforms enacted following the Second Vatican Council remains” (287-292).

 

REFLECTION


“History has proved a thousand times that there is nothing more dangerous for a religion, nothing is more likely to result in discontent, incertitude, division, and apostasy, than interference with the Liturgy and consequently with religious sensibility” (p. 285).

 

There is no doubt in me that this sentence struck me at most. However, I totally agree with this statement. There is a very popular attitude in the life of the Church―not only in respect to the Sacred Liturgy―that “Vatican II changed all that.” This is the popular slogan that summarizes what Benedict XVI called “a hermeneutic of rupture.” This is what the “spirit of the Council” meant at the grass-roots level. As Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger in the preface that there are many ways liturgists think about Liturgy especially talking about the "development of liturgy." It is important, he says, to distinguish "actions that are helpful and healing from those that are violent and destructive." Personally, I have got much insight by reading this book. I learn to keep myself away from archeological enthusiasm but in the same time also pastoral pragmatism. In this book, Dom Alcuin Reid offers a "wealth of material" to highlight those principals and actions which guide or hinder the healthy organic growth of the liturgy through the centuries.

For me this book is an extremely scholarly work (25-page bibliography, over 1000 footnotes!). However, I am grateful because I have an opportunity to read it. By learning the development of liturgy in the history, I aware of being more attentive and not to be reactive with regard to face the challenges of the (future) Church. Futhermore, if a "reform of the reform" is to occur in the Church, and if it is to remain faithful to Tradition, it must follow the principles of authentic growth detailed in this book by Dom Alcuin Reid. As John Henry Cardinal Newman once said, "To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant."



Architecture in Communion


·      Author: Steven J. Scholoeder
·      Pages: 243 pages + Bibliography, Glossary and Index
·      Publisher:  Ignasius Press, San Francisco (1998)
·      Language: English

About the Author

Steven Joseph Schloeder received the bachelor of architecture cum laude from Arizona State University in 1984. Schloeder is a licensed architect (Arizona, California), practicing nationally in the United States in all aspects of Roman Catholic sacred architecture, through his firm Liturgical Environs, PC.

Structure

Introduction
Part I
Chapter One             An architectural Response to Vatican II
Chapter Two             Art, Architecture, and Theology
Chapter Three           An Architecture for the Mass
Chapter Four             Furnishing the Sanctuary
Chapter Five             Designing for the Other Sacraments and Rites
Chapter Six                Domus Ecclesiae: The Parish Community
Chapter Seven          Sacred Images in the Church
Chapter Eight            Domus Dei: The Church as Icon
Chapter Nine            Catholic Architecture in the third millennium

Index

Scope

“Architecture in Communion” book emerges from Schloeder's apprehension when he found many modern Catholic churches to be banal, uninspiring, and frequently even liturgically bizarre. Especially since the Second Vatican Council, he saw that Western Catholicism has been moving even farther away from the centuries-old tradition of great ecclesiastical architecture. There are many reasons ascribed for this phenomenon: a disordered desire to “keep with the times” (up to date), clericalism, the insignificance of the Church in the modern world, and the intellectual poverty of modern architecture are but a few common explanations. However, He believes that the actual problem and also the solution lies elsewhere.


The heart and purpose of this book are to find appropriate arrangements and considerations for church buildings that are infused with a genuine spirit of the Second Vatican Council. The goal is to enliven the parish community (which is the true Church built of living stones in Christ) with a material church building designed to serve and further the primary vocation to become a community of love, which must mean a people of sacrifice and redemption. More than a mere monument to God, the church building finds its true purpose as a means to the sanctification of his people. It is worth to note also that Schloeder was not seeking a return to any previous style of building like another traditionalist because he also believes that there is no single “Catholic style of architecture.”

 

THESIS


Schloeder wants to underline three core functions of the Christian architecture especially of the church that become the vision of the Vatican Council, as follows:
- the sanctification of believers,
- the building of communities of love and service,
- moreover, the true humanizing of the individual and society
For pursuing this goal, he organized his book simply:
  • The first three chapters place the modern Catholic church building in it’s proper theological, sociological, historical, and liturgical settings. These chapters provide a common understanding of the agenda of the Second Vatican Council, the relationship of the Church to the arts and her artists and architects, and a discussion of the nature and dynamics of the Eucharistic Sacrifice.
  • The next three chapters examine the specific architectural requirements of the church building.
    • Chapter 4 examines the sanctuary furnishings regarding their liturgical, canonical, and symbolic components.
    • Chapter 5 looks at the architectural needs of the other sacraments and rites;
    • Chapter 6 considers the social and communal aspects of the parish buildings.
  • The last three chapters are ordered to help the architect and the community regain a monographic understanding of the church building
    • Chapter 7 discusses the idea of sacred images: the history and theology of the icon, as well as the place of the sacred image in the church today, are considered.
    • Chapter 8, the building as a whole is considered in its symbolic aspects, from both liturgical and historical perspectives.
    • Finally, Chapter 9 examines the questions about the form of the church building. Here the relationships between architectural massing, function, location, detail, and symbol are explored, with positive suggestions for regaining an iconic (a sacramental) appreciation of the church building.
Schloeder did not give many concrete solutions to the problems. Instead, he prefers to call attention to passages from the Church’s documents so that the reader may consider them carefully. He is not interested in suggesting that any one particular form was somehow the “ideal” or the “right way” to do the Christian architecture. His concern for design is not only about the result but the process.
Therefore, in this book he has given the Church’s guidelines so the architect and the community together may carefully consider them to find their inspiration. He believes that the Church used the similar way in guiding all creative activity, whether by artists, liturgists, or theologians. By setting limits, the Church protects not only her mission and the deposit of faith entrusted to her but the work of the individual. The Church gives the individual these limits or guidelines not as rules to be blindly obeyed. Rather, they are safeguards. He likes to use G. IC. Chesterton’s analogy, the Church builds a “corral of orthodoxy” in which the believer is safe to run freely. One venture outside the corral at one’s risk. Church architecture is very much “built theology,” and so the forms of the building must strive to “speak” the truths they represent. The risk for the theologian leaving the corral is heresy. The risk for the artist or architect is, at best, idiosyncratic isolation from the continuum of sacred art and architecture or, at worst, meaninglessness.

SOME CRITICS


Schloeder is guided by his presuppositions to interpret facts in a certain way. For instance, from a few examples of liturgical distortions, he generalizes to the confusion of all modern liturgy. Some of his claims are simply not true. For example, he asserts that modern liturgists have adopted the notion of the People of God to the exclusion of that of the Body of Christ. He finds such a dichotomy unwarranted. In fact, Schloeder introduces his own dichotomy when he says that the liturgy is primarily about the worship of God and not about the gathering of the people. Schloeder 's tone is condescending at times, as when he remarks that the barrenness of contemporary church buildings reflects the barrenness of contemporary theology. He sees his task to be that of rediscovering the true message about church buildings found in Vatican II, a message allegedly distorted by modern liturgists.
Schloeder 's final chapter gives in broad outline what he conceives to be the requirements for Catholic architecture in the third millennium. The church building cannot look like the other buildings around it because it is an icon of the house of God and the Body of Christ. He means by this that a church must work as a place for liturgy, must look like a church, and must express its interior arrangement in its external structure. He gives some examples of what he means; they are buildings that most liturgists would find acceptable. However, Schloeder excludes other possible designs because of his ideological stance, which demands that the building "look like a church." In this, he opts for some transcultural form which, while open to some variation throughout the ages, remains, in fact, the same. This form looks suspiciously like the Romanesque, medieval, and Renaissance churches of the past.

REFLECTION


Living in Rome made me become a witness of the richness of the Christian faith manifest in the Christian architectures. I used to read (and also, I read once again in this book) that the basic architectural requirement of the Church is that places of worship be “truly worthy and beautiful, signs and symbols of heavenly realities.”. When I lived in Indonesia, I cannot understand this idea very well because the church is very similar each other. However, here, in Rome, it is just like another world of the Christian architecture for me. There are many abundance manifestations of the richness of the Christian faith in almost all church that I have visited until now. Reading this book for me is like giving a subtitle to all Christian architecture that I saw so that I can understand better. Schloeder’s educates me to open my eyes to the richness of our faith. His sensitivity to all aspects of his subject makes this book an invaluable reference guide for all students, and professionals, of ecclesiastical architecture.

Now I understand that to build a church, the Church requires “the general plan of the sacred building be such that it reflects in some way the whole assembly.”. There is a danger when constructing a church by stressing communality over the centuries-old liturgical emphasis on the awesome mystery of the Lord’s sacrifice and eschewing traditional architectural symbolism, and by doing that many churches have become merely functional gathering places. The architect must work to create a sense of place for the community, to augment the individual’s awareness that it is God who has called the Church together to be present among them. Too often we have settled for easy solutions, e.g., ‘liturgy in the round, dining room or lounge, as if Christ’s gathered faithful were a [theatrical] audience!”

KOMUNI DAHI (Communion by [using] the Forehead) A brief analysis of one form of Inculturation in Indonesia

INTRODUCTION
In Indonesia, we have three ways to receive communion, namely: Komuni Tangan (Communion by Hands), Komuni Mata (Communion by Eyes) and Komuni Dahi (Communion by the forehead). Several times I went to several dioceses in Indonesia, I found this practice of Komuni Dahi widely practiced. Perhaps these three terms are very strange for liturgists in Europe because in Europe there are only two ways to receive communion, by hand or by the tongue. These three terms of "how to receive communion" are just only expressions of Indonesian language and It has a special meaning. For Indonesian Catholics, in general, the term “Communion” means accepting the Lord Jesus Christ in the form of bread that the priest has consecrated in the Eucharist. However, in the daily spiritual life of the faithful, communion has a broader meaning: "to accept Jesus in its various manifestations.” Therefore, there are three terms of how to receive Communion, whose explanation is as follows:
·         Komuni Tangan (Communion by Hands): Communion by hand means the acceptance of the Body of Christ (Sacred Host) in the celebration of the Eucharist from the hands of priests or extraordinary minister of holy communion[1] by hand. In Indonesia, the faithful are more prevalent to receive communion by hand than the tongue.
·         Komuni Mata (Communion by Eyes): This term is raised by the liturgists in Indonesia as a liturgical catechesis for the faithful. The priests use the term “communion by eyes” to invite the faithful to look at the Body/Blood of Jesus when he lifts the sacred host/wine after saying the words of consecration in the Eucharistic prayer. This invitation is necessary because most of the faithful bow their heads while raising their hands above the forehead as the priest lifts the body and blood of Jesus.[2] The term Communion of Eyes invites the people to stare Jesus that is being raised by the priest in the form of the sacred bread/wine. Therefore, the term “communion by eyes” means contemplating the Body of Christ that is being lifted by the priest with the use of the eyes.
·         Komuni Dahi[3] (Communion by the forehead): unlike the two terms above, the Komuni Dahi is a blessing by priests or priest’s assistant, after the ritual of communion, on the forehead of children/catechumens/Catholics who have some impediments to receive the holy communion. Why is it called Communion? As already explaining above, the "rite" is called Communion because at the moment people are aware of the presence of a priest acting as “In persona Christi” who came to bless them. How this "rite" is carried out will be described further in the section description.

OBJECT OF STUDY
After a glimpse of the description above, the object of study in this paper is a rite (Komuni Dahi) that does not exist in the Editio Typica but always performed in the celebration of the Eucharist in Indonesia. The author chose this theme to be appointed as a material because it realized how this practice is already practiced long enough (approximately since around 1980) and spread across almost all regions in Indonesia. Unfortunately, the authors did not find any official documents or scholarly writing discuss this “additional rites.” For that reason, it often appears the debate among some of the liturgist in Indonesia in addressing this matter.

DESCRIPTION OF THE RITE
When did this rite be performed
After the rite of Communion at the Sunday celebration of eucharistic.
The Subject of the rite
There are quite a lot of people involved in this rite such as:
·         Children who have not received communion yet (because they do not have enough age)
·         Infants and their parents
·         some Sunday school teacher who help to direct the child to line up with a nice, neatly and orderly
·         The catechumens (baptismal candidates)
·         Catholics who have some impediments to receiving the holy communion (usually due to problems in their marriage)
·         Priest (and sometimes assisted by extraordinary ministers)
How this rite is practiced
In general, the practice of Komuni Dahi in parishes is almost the same. However, since the Rite of Komuni Dahi is not written in any liturgical book, in practice there is sometimes little slight variation here and there.
At the celebration of the Sunday Eucharist, after the communion rite is over, the children (who have not received Communion) stand in a line like one who will receive communion and advance to the altar, but with arms crossed in front of their chests. However, not only the children but also babies are carried by their parents to come to the front of the altar to come before the priest for a blessing. On this occasion, often catechumens also come forward to receive blessings. In fact, Catholics who have some impediments to receiving the holy communion step forward to ask for this blessing.
Meanwhile, the priest stands in front of the altar, greets them and blesses them by touching their heads or making the sign of the cross on their foreheads. After receiving the blessing of the priest, they return to their respective seats as if they had received Holy Communion.[4] (see Picture 1, in the appendix, for the illustration).

THE MEANING OF KOMUNI DAHI
From the perspective of culture
Almost the same as other Asian countries, the Indonesian has an unyielding altruism culture. A culture that makes people love to share everything with his fellow man. In Indonesia, we have a tradition called Kenduri or ater-ater. Kenduri/ater-ater[5] is an activity that person does when someone is about to manifest his or her thankfulness by inviting neighbors to eat together or at least give food (in a food box) and distributed to all neighbors equally. If one or two neighbors did not come to the event or did not get the food, then it was regarded as something very offensive, even if it was done by accident. In Indonesian culture, it is important to make sure that everyone gets their share. Social inequality is something to be avoided because it creates an uncomfortable feeling among citizens and is often even regarded as an insult. This powerful element of altruism is what would lead to the creation of an "additional rite" in the ritual of communion as a process of adaptation to Indonesian culture. It seems that the kenduri/Ater-ater culture is so affecting the faithful to view the Eucharistic as a banquet. In the Eucharistic, all the faithful give thanks to God for all the blessings they have received. In that same celebration, everyone gets the blessing of God. A very special blessing is received in Holy Communion, that is when the Lord Jesus Himself is shared in the form of bread. The culture of altruism makes the people feel that everyone who attends the celebration must get the blessing equally. On the one hand, there is an uncomfortable feeling (communal) when some people may accept the body of Christ (blessing) and some are not. However, on the other hand, the people are also aware that:
·         Children are still not worthy/ready to receive the Body of Christ because they do not yet understand the true value of it
·         The catechumens are also still in their preparation for recognizing the Catholic Church
·         The people who are unable to receive communion (usually due to marriage cases) are also not worthy to receive communion in a state of sin
Therefore, finally, there is an adaptation made to alleviate “the cultural inconvenience.” The Komuni Dahi is held to bridge the gap between people who may receive the Body of Christ and those who have not received the Body of Christ. With the communion of the forehead at least everyone who cannot receive the Body of Christ can get the Blessings of the priest. It is certain that the blessing cannot replace the excellent value of the Body of Christ. Communion by the forehead is taken as the least of the bad (minus malum) for the sacred liturgical celebration.
From the Liturgical Viewpoint
This communion of the forehead can also be seen as a greeting to the children present at the Eucharistic celebration. We knew together that the celebration of the liturgy is tough to understand by children. Communion by the forehead is considered to help familiarize the children to be more familiar/accustomed to the celebration of the Eucharist. Those who have not been able to receive communion line up to receive blessings on their foreheads. This communion of the forehead also helps the parents of children who have not received the communion to dampen the hearts of their children when the child sees that their parents may receive the Body of Christ while they are not. The Communion by the forehead also avoids the parents of sacrilege sin because often there are some parents, whom to ease the roar of their jealous children that cannot receive the Body of Christ, flake a little piece of the sacred host received to be distributed to their children. Also, the Communion by the forehead also becomes an opportunity to embrace those who have not/can not receive communion, especially catechumens and those who have canonical obstacles to receive communion, so that they remain welcome and feel placed in the source and summit of our Christian life, The Eucharist.

EVALUATION
In this section, the author will attempt to evaluate the adaptation of the addition of the Communion of forehead in light of the principles of liturgical inculturation. To analyze this rite the author uses four important criteria that need to be considered in the inculturation process of Paulo Giglioni's writings (Chapter VI).
In general, this "Communion by the forehead" does not want to create a new liturgy. The Rite of Communion by the forehead appears to bridge the deeply altruistic culture that exists in Indonesia, specifically to reduce the gap between those who receive communion and those who have not been/have some impediments from receiving communion.
A. Criteria of Faith
This criterion of faith indicates that a proper process of Inculturation is a process that makes the faithful more able to live the paschal mystery of Christ; directing people to the Kingdom of Heaven; respecting to the Word of God and People of God; and realizing the ultimate goal of human life that is to unite with God .
In my opinion, Communion by the forehead is precisely a form of human longing to be always united with God, especially those who have not / some impediments to receiving Holy Communion. This communion of foreheads is an attempt made by the shepherds of the soul to keep unifying those who have not / cannot receive this Body of Christ despite the intercession of priestly blessing. It is necessary to do some catechesis first for the faithful to truly understand that this priest's blessing in no way replaces or displaces the excellent value of the Body of Christ present in the Blessed Sacrament. By doing the Communion by the forehead, they increase their desire to be more united with Christ by eating His Body by seeking repentance and growth in faith from day to day.
B. Liturgical Criteria
This liturgical criterion indicates that a real inculturation process always keeps the faithful from all forms of superstition and errors and even more harmony with the authentic liturgical spirit. Thus, a good inculturation process recognizes that in the liturgy there are immutable elements and can change (SC 21).
In the writer's reflection, liturgically there is something less appropriate if it refers to the standard liturgical norms, which states that in the celebration of the Eucharist there is usually only one common blessing during the Closing rite. However, this practice of Komuni Dahi is far from any superstition, for there are children, catechumens, and Catholics who are unable to receive communion who want to manifest their faith and harmonize themselves with the liturgical spirit of responding to God's call to holiness. This occasion also becomes for them the encounter between man and the risen God. Practically indeed, in reality, the practice of Komuni Dahi does a little disturbance to other people because when many children standing in a row together would inevitably appear a bit of rowdy atmosphere in the church. The faithful who have just received Holy Communion may be troubled by this commotion. However, with the help of Sunday school teachers and continuous training, this noise usually can be kept on a day-to-day basis.
C. Ecclesiology Criteria
This ecclesiological criterion indicates that a good inculturation process always shows a genuine nature of the Church, which has both divine and human character in it. Therefore, every form of adaptation must respect unity and continuity between the Universal and the Particular Church (SC 2).
In the writer's reflection, it is ecclesiological true that this “addition rite” only appeared about 20-30 years ago and no ancient textual reference shows the continuity of the use of this rite since centuries ago. One of the scriptural texts commonly quoted by Indonesian priests to justify this practice is when Jesus blessed the children who came to Him (e.g. cf. Mt., 13-15). However, of course, this argument cannot be accounted for because the liturgy is not just a dramatization of the passages in Scripture. However, in this Komuni Dahi, the identity of the Church appear clearer. The existence of this Komuni Dahi shows that the Church consists of: children (who become the Church's future hope); The catechumens (who show the works of the holy spirit who continually cultivate faith and call people to believe in God until this very day); and sinners (represented by those who are unable to receive communion, but the work of Jesus' atonement can be felt clearer in them).
D. Anthropological Criteria
This anthropological criterion indicates that a real inculturation process is a process that prioritizes respect for the culture that shapes humans, the human feelings that exist in the culture and promotes the mutualistic integration between liturgy and culture.
In the writer's reflection, the human anthropological dimension is the most wanted dimension in this adaptation. Komuni Dahi wants to lift the anthropological side of Indonesian culture. The Komuni Dahi greatly accommodates the adamant culture of altruism in Indonesian culture and respects the human feelings in it. Indeed, the liturgy should not rely on individual subjective feelings, but also cannot just ignore it.

CONCLUSION
Since coming to Italy, one striking difference, the author feels, with Indonesia is about the enthusiasm of the faithful who attended the Liturgical Celebration. As far as the author's experience, the atmosphere of the liturgical celebrations in Indonesia is much livelier than the liturgical celebrations in some parishes in Rome, at least regarding the quantity of the number of people present. Still fresh in my memories, the last celebration of Easter Vigil, at that time I celebrated the celebration of Easter vigil with the number of people less than 100 people. Instead, In Indonesia, almost all parishes in every Easter vigil, the number of faithful always overflow (more than 1000 people per parish). This experience makes the authors grateful that the enthusiasm of the faithful in Indonesia towards the sacred liturgy is very high. However, this enthusiasm also that often makes people so creative in making changes that are often said to be "renewal" in the sacred liturgy that must be dealt with wisely.
Speaking of Komuni Dahi, from my brief analysis (theologically, culturally, and pastorally), I did not find any grave errors or superstition in this practice. However, it needs a thorough analysis to deepen it. It is the duty of liturgical experts in Indonesia to help bishops consider the usefulness and urgency of this adaptation with diligence and wisdom. Then after careful consideration (theologically, anthropologically, historically, and pastorally) is obtained (SC 23. 37), if it is deemed necessary as soon as possible to be submitted to the Apostolic See for immediate implementation of the guidelines by SC 40. One small input if this rite will be integrated with the sacred liturgy is that the priest/extraordinary ministers should first put the ciborium that contains the Body of Christ on the altar before giving his blessing in Komuni Dahi to prevent undesirable things.[6]
This evaluation process should continue to deepen and evaluate so many variations of practice liturgy that developed in Indonesia so that people not only do liturgy just because of habit but with full awareness so that bear fruit in their daily life.

Bibliography

P. GIGLIONI, INCULTURAZIONE: Teoria e prassi, Edizioni San Paolo, Milano 2015.
A. J. CHUPUNGCO (ed.), Handbook for Liturgical Studies, 2: Fundamental Liturgy, Claretian Publications, Philippines 2004.
A. J. CHUPUNGCO, Liturgical Inculturation: Sacramentals, Religiosity, and Cathecesis, The Liturgical Press Collegeville, Minnesota 1992.



[1] Starting 2000 KWI (Bishop Conference of Indonesia) establishes the term “Asisten Imam” (which mean Priest’s Assistant) for calling extraordinary ministers of holy communion, but there are still many dioceses in Indonesia using the less precise / ambiguous term “Pro-diakon” until now
[2] This gesture appears in the Liturgy because of the strong influence of Javanese culture. Javanese culture is a culture with a thick element of feudalism. In Javanese culture, it is not polite to look from eye to eye to someone who has a higher position than us, even when speaking. As a result, a child should not look into the eyes of his parents when they are giving advice or talking to them. People should not look up when meeting a King and they should listen to the King who is speaking with his head down. So, when a person does not look directly at the other person, he is giving a high honor. This is very contrary to European culture. Therefore, when the priest lifts the Body and Blood of Christ after praying the institution words, people with strong Javanese culture will automatically bow their heads because they realize that at that moment Jesus, King of Kings, is present before them.
[3] Further, in this paper, the author will use this term to refer to Communion using the forehead
[4] See Picture 1 in the appendix for the illustration
[5] See Picture 2 and 3 in the appendix for the illustration
[6] See Picture 4 in the appendix for the illustration